Brooklyn appeals court throws out gun possession charge, cites ineffective counsel
The Appellate Division, 2nd Department vacated a defendant’s gun possession conviction on the grounds that he was not represented — at the trial level — by an effective defense counsel.
Tony Canales was convicted in 2008 of murder of Antonio Bruce and criminal possession of a weapon. At trial, Brooklyn prosecutor Lawrence Fredella showed a videotape of Canales chasing a man purported to be Bruce who is seen falling and tumbling out of view. Fredella claimed at trial that Bruce fell as a result of being shot by Canales; Canales’ trial attorney conceded that assumption during his closing argument.
After the jury began deliberating, Canales raised the argument that the man being chased in the video was in fact not Bruce. Canales was convicted and filed a post-judgment motion to vacate the murder conviction and the gun possession charge on the grounds of prosecutorial misconduct and ineffective counsel.