OPINION: Where’s the beef for Cuomo’s L-Train partial shutdown?
Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s announcement that the work on the Canarsie Line tunnel scheduled to start in April will be changed lacks critical details.
How much longer will it take for NYC Transit and private contractors to complete work with only overnight and weekend closures than the previously announced 15-month 24/7 project duration? MTA and NYCDOT have already spent millions in planning, environmental review, design and engineering, assuming a 15-month 24/7 shut down. They normally would perform value engineering, a method to look at alternative methods for performing work, which would result in cost savings. This work was performed by experienced engineers and engineering consulting firms. They have first-hand knowledge of how the nation’s largest subway system works.
Cuomo’s outside experts came from the Columbia and Cornell University world of academia. If their new design idea was used abroad, both the MTA and NYC Transit President Andy Byford (who previously ran transit systems in London and Toronto) would have discovered it under value engineering.