Brooklyn Boro

SKETCHES OF COURT: Motions pending to set aside verdict in hit-and-run trial

November 17, 2017 By Alba Acevedo Brooklyn Daily Eagle
Court sketch by Alba Acevedo
Share this:

n this courtroom sketch, Hon. Pamela Fisher listens as defendant’s attorney John T. Morale (standing), of the law offices of Richard T. Lau and Assocs., summarizes his arguments before the jury in the pedestrian-motor vehicle accident trial Nieves v. 8 Avenue Furniture. At issue was the determination of liability

Evelyn Nieves was walking across Fifth Avenue in Sunset Park in front of her brother and his friend when she was felled by a hit-and-run driver in January 2012. Police responded, and an accident report was filed. Nieves alleges to have spotted the commercial van and driver in the area two weeks later. Nieves is represented by Kenneth V. Madden (at left), of the law offices of Cherny & Podolsky. 

On the stand, the driver, through a court interpreter, denied striking a pedestrian or being involved in the accident. In summation, Morale cited inconsistencies in testimony for the plaintiff with the police report, inclusive of who spotted the partial license plate number, who spoke to the responding officer at the time of the accident, the driver description, and whether the plaintiff was midblock or in the crosswalk. 

Subscribe to our newsletters

The jury determined that the van and driver were involved in the accident, but that the defendant’s negligence was not a substantial factor in causing the accident. Motions to set aside the inconsistent verdict as against the weight of evidence, or for a new trial, are pending in Kings County Civil Term. Court reporter Miriam Kaplan recorded the proceedings. 


Leave a Comment


Leave a Comment