Three men who own food businesses in Mill Basin have been charged with bribery for allegedly offering winnings from a valuable Super Bowl box to a New York City Department of Health official in exchange for a warning about impending inspections.
Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez identified the defendants as John DiSanto, 50, of Bergen Beach; his brother, Jack DiSanto, 47, of Bergen Beach; and Robert Cuba, 55, of Staten Island.
They were arraigned Monday before Brooklyn Supreme Court Justice Sharen Hudson on an indictment in which they are each charged with one count of second- and third-degree bribery. Their businesses, Gourmet Grill, Inc., Frozen Planet Yogurt, LLC, and Mill Basin Bagel Café, Inc., were also arraigned on the same charges. The defendants were released without bail and ordered to return to court on Jan. 19, 2022.
The District Attorney said that around January 2020, John DiSanto allegedly communicated with a Department of Health employee by text, seeking advance notice of inspections in exchange for a Super Bowl box. The employee reported the alleged bribe attempt to the Department of Investigation, which used an undercover investigator to communicate with the defendant.
DiSanto subsequently communicated with the undercover, whom he allegedly believed to be a DOH employee who could give him advance notice of inspections to be performed at his restaurant, Gourmet Grill, located at 6334 Avenue N in Brooklyn, according to the District Attorney’s Office.
DiSanto allegedly promised the undercover two lucrative boxes in an annual Super Bowl pool, explaining that he would cover the cost of the $1,000 boxes which could ultimately lead to a $50,000 payoff.
In exchange, the undercover agreed to give DiSanto advance notice of the annual DOH inspections at Gourmet Grill, as well as Frozen Yogurt Planet, located at 6340 Avenue N (owned by DiSanto’s brother and co-defendant, Jack DiSanto) and Mill Basin Bagel Café, located at 6319 Avenue N (owned by DiSanto’s cousin and co-defendant, Robert Cuba).
The following transcript of an alleged conversation in January 2020 between the undercover and DiSanto laid out the arrangement:
JD: You’ll have your sets of numbers and if you hit, you come see me and you come collect. And if you don’t hit, you’re in it next year.
UC: Yeah
JD: But you just have to give me your word that you’re going to help me.
UC: Ok, so just – you want me to look after the bagel.
JD: My three stores. My family stores.
UC: Bagel, Frozen –
JD: And Gourmet Grill.
UC: And Gourmet Grill. And then just, you’ll give me the two boxes and then –
JD: They’re yours forever.
UC: And I’ll look through the system?
JD: All you have to do is tell me, John, ah, we have a … [A former DOH employee] described the person that would come –
UC: Ok.
In a later conversation, the defendant allegedly said that he and his co-defendants need advance notice of one week for any upcoming inspections “because we do get nervous, I’m going to admit it. We wanna get it over with because it’s kind of a little taxing for us. So, if they don’t come, then we get mad because we prepare and then we have to reprepare, and so you just gotta give me the heads up.”
DiSanto allegedly added: “Ok. And [UC], I want you to become friends with me. I want you to meet my brother, and I want you to come meet, and I want you to – I want you to win. Because I want you to be comfortable, I want you to be like, I’m excited to help these people. That’s what I want.”
In February 2020, it is alleged, the undercover met up with DiSanto to collect $16,000 cash in winnings from the Super Bowl boxes. The undercover and DiSanto allegedly met again, in February 2021, after the Super Bowl, and DiSanto allegedly gave the undercover $4,000 to continue the arrangement, according to the District Attorney’s Office.
District Attorney Gonzalez said, “It is alleged that these defendants attempted to corrupt and circumvent Health Department protocols that are in place for a reason: to ensure sanitary conditions and protect the public. I commend the city employee who, when allegedly offered a bribe, reported it to DOI. We will now seek to hold the defendants accountable.”
