Brooklyn Boro

Task 1 in Trump Organization trial: picking a neutral jury

October 24, 2022 Larry Neumeister and Michael R. Sisak, Associated Press
Share this:

Donald Trump’s company went on trial Monday in a criminal tax case and the first task facing the court is a big one: picking a jury of New Yorkers who don’t have a strong opinion about the former president.

Manhattan prosecutors say the Trump Organization helped top executives avoid income taxes on job perks such as rent-free apartments and luxury cars.

Trump himself isn’t on trial and isn’t expected to testify. But the judge and lawyers in the case will likely be looking to keep people off the jury if they have unshakably strong feelings about the Republican, who isn’t liked in his hometown.

Subscribe to our newsletters

In the 2020 presidential election, 87% of Manhattan voters supported Democrat Joe Biden for president. Trump got 12% of the vote.

“We’re figuring it is going to be, probably, a good solid week for jury selection,” said one of the Trump Organization’s lawyers, William Brennan, as he arrived at the courthouse Monday. ”When you boil it all down, it is a garden-variety tax case. And that’s how they should look at it.”

Judge Juan Manuel Merchan started things off Monday by bringing 132 prospective jurors into the courtroom.

They all stood and raised their right hands and were sworn in. Then the judge addressed them for over 20 minutes, describing the case and explaining that they’re seeking unbiased jurors who will decide it solely on the evidence.

Merchan told the jury pool the trial would last about six weeks, and that during the case jurors were likely to hear Trump’s name and the names of his three eldest children, Ivanka, Eric and Donald Trump Jr.

The trial is expected to center on the actions and testimony of longtime Trump Organization executive Allen Weisselberg, who pleaded guilty in August to accepting more than $1.7 million worth of untaxed perks from the company.

Trump has decried the probe as a “political witch hunt.” The company’s lawyers have said the Trump Organization played by the rules.

If convicted, the company could be fined more than $1 million. A guilty verdict could hamper its ability to get loans and make deals.

Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg inherited the prosecution when he took office in January. Bragg has taken a cautious approach with Trump, declining so far to bring charges against him personally in what’s now a three-year investigation.

The jury selection process could take several days, especially if people in the pool express reservations about their ability to be neutral. Getting a panel with an open mind, though, could be critical to avoiding a mistrial.

In the spring, another trial in a nearby federal courthouse ended in a mistrial because of tensions between jurors about political views. That case involved associates of former Trump adviser Steve Bannon who were accused of defrauding a charity founded to help pay for a wall along the U.S. border with Mexico.

Eleven jurors in that case sent a note to the judge asking that another juror be removed because that person had shown an anti-government bias and accused all the others of being liberals. The judge declined and the jury ultimately couldn’t agree on a verdict.

Leave a Comment

Leave a Comment