Brooklyn Boro

Listen to neighborhood stories

February 12, 2021 Ed Mullins
Share this:

Reducing something as massive, sprawling, and diverse as New York City to fit into the smallness of a political campaign diminishes the depth and character of our neighborhoods. Insisting that New York City is the sum of its problems, as so many of the candidates to be our next mayor are doing, is insulting. Worse yet, the tone-deaf and desperate appeals some candidates are being spoon-fed by their handlers ignore the history and richness and varied experiences of the block-by-block tapestry of our five boroughs.

Cops know about stories because every interaction we have is a story that speaks to the complexity of the job and the city. Consider the enduring popularity of the famous closing of each episode of Naked City —“There are eight million stories in the naked city. This has been one of them,” and the iconic opening of Law & Order — “In the criminal justice system, the people are represented by two separate yet equally important groups: The police, who investigate crime, and the district attorneys, who prosecute the offenders. These are their stories.”

What police do resonates because people understand how important our work is and they are honest about their own stories. When politicians and candidates vilify police in order to fit in with protestors much younger than them or go after cops in an attempt to ride a wave of social media activism, actual voters understand that they’re being talked down to.

Subscribe to our newsletters

Our neighborhoods are filled with stories that matter – stories that speak to authenticity, grit, and loyalty. Like police, including the frontline supervisors I have the honor of representing, our neighborhoods know what works and what doesn’t. The field of mayoral candidates running around the city, in-person and online, are not equal in their authenticity or ability to speak to the fullness of the city.

While the mayoral race continues and shifts, consider these neighborhood truths:

Homeowners in East Flatbush see through the spin just as easily as Parent-Teacher Association members in Douglaston. Small business owners, whether living in Tottenville or Whitestone, or Soundview know when candidates aren’t making sense. Longtime residents of Brighton Beach and Harlem know when the fix is in. Sikhs in Richmond Hill and Indo-Caribbeans and Bengalis in Ozone Park share their distrust of gentrifying activists with Albanians in Pelham Parkway. Celebrity endorsements don’t mean much in Co-Op City or the Brigham Park Co-Ops. The Village — East, and West — has a history the rest of America reads about, survived a plague, and has no patience for talking points. Coney Island neighbors and Washington Heights stalwarts know what’s authentic and what’s bunk. NYCHA residents citywide have grievances long ignored by all levels of government, are increasingly organized, and will take their righteous anger out on those who have promised but haven’t delivered. Orthodox and Hasidic neighborhoods in every borough worry about spikes in anti-Semitism.

Cops know all of the neighborhoods in New York City. Public safety is a priority we share with the communities we serve, alongside healthy skepticism of the liberal groupthink hoping to cement control of City Hall and Albany.

Law enforcement is the foundation of all good things. Cops and all other first responders make and preserve the space for safe streets, safe commutes, safe playgrounds, safe buildings, and safe small businesses. Recovery from the grinding COVID economic depressions depends on police being able to do their job.

The Queens Democratic Party recently hosted a mayoral candidate forum via Zoom. One candidate included an honest discussion of professional law enforcement, referencing the use of statistics in allocating police resources and the pivotal role of Jack Maple and CompStat. Police work is difficult and complicated, so it was encouraging to hear at least one leading candidate speak openly about its importance.

Our next mayor valuing police and the neighborhoods they protect is especially important since the large incoming class of new City Councilmembers will likely be dominated by the radical left. Tiffany Caban, who was nearly the Queens District Attorney, is now running for City Council in Astoria and is already a contender to be the next Council Speaker. Her own description of her public safety platform, reported by the Queens Post, is scary: “My goal at the end of the day is to ultimately get to a place where we are no longer funding police — period. That is not going to happen tomorrow, that is not going to happen next year, but it’s important to have that goal in mind — understanding that there is no connection between police and public safety and we have to stop pretending that there is.”

Elections are choices with very real consequences. Let’s make sure this story doesn’t turn into a nightmare.

Ed Mullins is president of the Sergeants Benevolent Association of the NYPD.


Leave a Comment


Leave a Comment