Brooklyn Boro

Report: Cobble Hill nursing home has most coronavirus deaths

April 17, 2020 Marina Villeneuve and Jim Mustian Associated Press

ALBANY, N.Y. (AP) — New York, by far the nation’s leader in coronavirus nursing home deaths, released details Friday on outbreaks in individual facilities after weeks of refusing to do so. The report revealed one home in Brooklyn where 55 people died and four others with at least 40 deaths.

“Every death is heartbreaking,” said Dr. Roy Goldberg, medical director at Kings Harbor Multicare Center, a 720-bed home in the Bronx which reported 45 fatalities. “These have been surreal times.”

The state’s count of multiple deaths at 68 nursing homes was based on a survey and is substantially incomplete. It accounted for less than half of the 2,477 nursing home deaths that have been reported in the state. It also didn’t include people who got sick in nursing homes, but then died at hospitals.

DAILY TOP BROOKLYN NEWS
News for those who live, work and play in Brooklyn and beyond

But it was the first time the state provided any information about homes that, according to an Associated Press tally, account for nearly 40% of the nation’s 6,461 deaths in such facilities.

At the top of the list with 55 deaths was Cobble Hill Health Center, a 300-bed facility in a 19th-century former hospital in Brooklyn.

A message was left for the center’s administrators seeking comment. Four ambulances arrived within an hour at the facility on Friday, underscoring the ongoing crisis. Police showed up to assist with the removal of bodies, including one that was wheeled out the front door.

A total of 19 homes in New York’s report listed 20 deaths or more.

The survey’s release came a day after New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s administration reversed course and promised transparency about the worst outbreaks, after previously saying residents at the hardest-hit homes deserved privacy. Few states have released such information.


Cuomo did not respond directly when asked at his daily coronavirus briefing why his administration had not alerted the public about the outbreaks sooner.

“We’ve been talking about nursing homes every day for the past 30 days,” Cuomo said. “We’ve said 157 times the most vulnerable population are seniors, the most vulnerable places are nursing homes. … I think we’ve been talking about it all along.”

The state’s list omitted homes with fewer than five deaths.

Emergency medical workers arrived at Cobble Hill Health Center on an emergency call on Friday. Photo: John Minchillo/AP

Connecticut released a similar list Thursday, reporting that eight nursing homes had at least 10 residents die. In Connecticut, nursing home residents account for 375 of the state’s 971 virus deaths.

Officials at several of the nursing homes on the list said they were doing their best, and attributed the high number of deaths to the fragility of their patients and difficulty in keeping the virus out, rather than substandard care.

“We have had our share of sadness,” Lina Scacco, an assistant vice president at Parker Jewish Institute for Health Care and Rehabilitation in New Hyde Park, where 38 people have died. “We’re all grieving here.”

Scacco said the facility, whose residents include war veterans and Holocaust survivors, was ravaged despite having infection control practices that exceed CDC and health department regulations and guidelines.

Now, she said, they’re planning virtual memorials for residents who’ve died, and grief counseling for staff members.

“This has been devastating to our families,” Scacco said.

Stephen Hanse, president and CEO of the New York State Health Facilities Association and the New York State Center for Assisted Living, said the figures reflect the fact that those facilities are dealing with extremely vulnerable patients.

“Outbreaks are not the result of inattentiveness or a shortcoming in our facilities,” he wrote in a statement. “The very nature of long-term care is a high touch environment where social distancing is not an option. Staff are helping residents with bathing, dressing, eating and other personal daily needs.”

He also blamed the state health department for worsening the situation by barring nursing homes from denying admission to patients with COVID-19 if they were medically stable.

Nursing homes have been known since the earliest days of the outbreak as likely trouble spots. A home in Washington state lost 43 residents early in the virus’s spread into the country.

Italy, which was hit before the U.S., is also in the midst of a nursing home crisis, with health officials estimating Friday that thousands of patients there have been killed by the virus.

Yet even with that early warning, many nursing homes remained without adequate supplies of personal protective equipment. Testing for residents and staff remains spotty, at best.

Federal officials in mid-March banned visitors, halted group activities and ordered mandatory screenings of workers for respiratory symptoms, but by then the virus had quietly spread widely.

Kings Harbor’s medical director, Goldberg, said staff members there created two dedicated COVID-19 units to treat infected patients and followed “every department of health and CDC recommendation and regulation.”

“Obtaining PPE has always been a struggle,” he added, “but we’ve always stayed one step ahead.”

An emergency medical worker cleaned a gurney as a member of the National Guard arrived outside Cobble Hill Health Center. Photo: John Minchillo/AP

New York state’s health commissioner, Howard Zucker, said the state is providing enough personal protective equipment for nursing homes and helping with staffing.

“We’re working with each individual nursing home to address that. We contact them and if there’s a need for PPE … we have stockpiles.”

Many nursing home administrators also previously declined to release information, leading Cuomo to say this week that the state would begin requiring homes to inform patients and their families within 24 hours if a resident got the virus or died.

Chris Laxton, executive director of the The Society for Post-Acute and Long-Term Care Medicine, applauded the state for releasing the data. But he said facilities still desperately need the state’s help.

“We continue to be in urgent need of PPE, especially gowns, test kits, and surge staff, to limit staff from traveling between buildings and risking additional spread,” Laxton said.

Some nursing homes have disclosed information voluntarily that differed from the numbers put out by the state Friday.

The state survey listed 10 deaths at the Montgomery Nursing and Rehabilitation Center, about 50 miles north of New York City, but facility Vice President Vincent Maniscalco said 21 residents have died recently. Eight of those residents, he said, had symptoms consistent with the virus but died prior to being tested.

“It’s been a very trying time for the staff, to lose residents they care for day in and day out,” Maniscalco said.

Outbreaks killed 46 at a nursing home in suburban Richmond, Virginia, and 22 at a home in central Indiana. County officials in northern New Jersey said Thursday that at least 26 patients had died at a nursing home in Andover.

An Associated Press report found infections were continuing to find their way into nursing homes because screening staff for a fever or questioning them about symptoms didn’t catch people who were infected but asymptomatic.

Associated Press writers Michael R. Sisak and David R. Martin contributed to this report.


Leave a Comment


Leave a Comment

3 Comments

  1. Robert Wachewski

    Why is anyone surprised about the Covis deaths in the Coble Hill nursing home? Face it. Most elderly people never come out after being admitted. My own mother died there last year; she was 96. It made no difference weather it was Covis or something else. I miss her just the same. The sad thing is that they couldn’t have their loved ones with them at the end. I visited my mother everyday. So at least she wasn’t alone. My sympathies to the families.

  2. The Cobble Hill facility is nonprofit. It has an interesting history. Once owned by Eugene Hollander, who was convicted of Medicaid fraud, part of his plea agreement was that it was turned over to a nonprofit. Originally the nonprofit board was mainly composed of Cobble Hill residents. I don’t know who is on the board now. There must be some board responsible for this tragedy. There’s a story here.

  3. Real sad to hear, sadly not surprising either,as someone with a family member in one, nursing homes can be problematic in normal times, this is a vulnerable pop., patients that are like sitting ducks, they can’t take care of themselves, put on a mask, take precautions as needed, so when infected staff members came in, it spreads like wildfire. Nursing homes admin. were really not prepare, needed to take better precautions, screening staff (CNA’s, cooks, janitorial) making sure that if they felt sick to go home. Need to do vigorous disinfecting too.