Brooklyn Boro

National Grid’s standoff with state threatens Brooklyn customers

August 26, 2019 Paula Katinas

National Grid is refusing to supply new gas hook-ups unless the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation grants a permit to an Oklahoma-based company to build a controversial $1 billion gas pipeline, effectively holding customers hostage, according to Brooklyn lawmakers and local homeowners.

Residents and civic leaders spoke out at a press conference that Assemblymember William Colton held outside his Gravesend office on Friday, demanding that National Grid turn on the gas.

Hundreds of customers in Brooklyn are currently without gas, according to Colton.

National Grid, which enjoys a legal monopoly to supply gas to parts of New York State, announced earlier this year that it would not process any new applications for gas service unless DEC grants a permit to Williams Companies, Inc., of Oklahoma to construct a 37-mile gas pipeline from New Jersey to New York that would allow National Grid to increase its gas capacity by 14 percent.

The pipeline, part of a Northeast Supply Enhancement Project, would be constructed underwater.

DEC rejected Williams’ previous permit application on the grounds that the company had not offered a detailed plan on how it would mitigate any environmental concerns. The construction process could unleash mercury and copper into New York’s waterways, DEC said in its rejection notice. Williams has re-applied for a permit.

But the tense standoff is hurting working families and mom-and-pop businesses, according to Colton, who represents Gravesend and parts of Bensonhurst and Dyker Heights.

“We are dealing with an emergency in our community,” Colton said. Houses, businesses and community-based organizations are all caught in a bind, he added.

DAILY TOP BROOKLYN NEWS
News for those who live, work and play in Brooklyn and beyond

The moratorium affects people seeking new gas service as well as those looking to have the gas turned back on after it had been off, Colton said.

Julie Levine said she bought a home and spent months renovating it only to learn that National Grid wouldn’t turn her gas on. “We bought a house in Park Slope. We spent our life savings renovating it. I called the gas company and was told they will not be providing me with gas,” she said, adding that she had played by the rules and had the gas turned off during the renovations because that is what she was required to do.

Levine said she and her family can’t move out of their apartment and into their newly renovated house. “We have nowhere to go. Our lease is up in a month,” she said.

Ansen Tang, office manager at the United Chinese Association of Brooklyn, said the organization, which operates out of a two-story building at 1787 Stillwell Ave. in Gravesend, might have to shut down its programs in the winter.

Ansen Tang, office manager for the United Chinese Association of Brooklyn, said the UCA is in danger of having to shut down its community center because of the gas service moratorium. Eagle photo by Paula Katinas

UCA provides English language lessons, yoga, student enrichment programs and food for senior citizens at its Stillwell Avenue center, which is located on the first floor of the building. The building owner is seeking to rent the second floor to a new tenant and wants separate gas lines serving each floor. UCA would need a new gas line on the first floor, according to Tang, who said National Grid refused the request.

“We cannot operate our center,” Tang said, adding that UCA serves more than 500 people who come to the center “to have a better quality of life.”

Colton charged that by refusing to service customers, National Grid is committing “a serious violation” of its agreement with the New York State Public Service Commission. The agreement allows National Grid to operate a monopoly.

Councilmember Mark Treyger, who represents Coney Island, Gravesend and parts of Bensonhurst, said the gas service moratorium disproportionately affects working people. A major corporation can afford to wait months or longer for a gas hook-up, he said. But a small, mom-and-pop business cannot afford to wait. “This is a crisis,” he said.

Treyger sought to cast doubt on National Grid’s assertions that it needs the Williams pipeline. “National Grid does not have a gas supply problem. They have a greed problem,” he said.

Indeed, customers who were refused gas service reported that National Grid urged them to call on their state legislators to support the Williams pipeline.

Karen Young, a spokesperson for National Grid, sent a statement from the company defending its policy.

“We’re equally as frustrated that we can’t serve requests for new or expanded gas service safely and reliably for our customers and communities without the necessary approvals for the Northeast Supply Enhancement Project (NESE),” the statement reads. “The infrastructure serving the region with gas supply has reached full capacity and is unable to meet growing demand. To add additional service without NESE would pose a risk to the operational integrity of our system and jeopardize reliability of service for the existing 1.8 million customers.”

Leave a Comment


Leave a Comment

2 Comments

  1. Captplanet

    Our governor has banned fracking for gas in New York State. Why should we expect citizens of other states to tolerant fracking when we won’t ourselves? Clearly National Grid needs to come up with a plan to reduce demand for its services. Instead it bullies its customers. That’s unacceptable and the state regulators should take necessary measures to bring National Grid into line.

  2. Bill Pearlman

    This is part of the progressive Democratic agenda. And the people bought it. I’m sympathetic but unless Julie Levine and Austin Tang voted Republican they have no reason to complain