Brooklyn Boro

Longer commutes could mean higher obesity rates, analysis show

August 1, 2019 Jeffery Harrell, Brianna Noonan and Measure of America
A male rubbed a woman’s breast with his elbow and then squeezed it on the L train on Thursday morning. AP Photo/Mary Altaffer
Share this:

When the L-train shutdown was announced, public health researchers published an extensive Health Impact Assessment report detailing a relationship between longer commute times and worse health outcomes.

Even though the shutdown was modified, reduced to a more benevolent slowdown, data from the Census Bureau shows that pockets of Brooklyn do face the kind of commutes concerning to health researchers.

That data, combined with the New York City Department of Health’s Community Health Survey, reveals an existing relationship between commute times and obesity.

Subscribe to our newsletters

An analysis by Measure of America, a project of the nonprofit Social Science Research Council, showed that where more adults spend upward of an hour commuting, more adults are obese.

Although the factors don’t necessarily cause one another, the relationship between commute time and obesity highlights the public health importance of access to efficient transportation. While obesity is not an exact indicator of someone’s health and fitness, it is linked to diabetes and heart conditions.

In Coney Island and Brighton Beach, about four in every 10 people spend more than one hour commuting each way. It’s also estimated that more than one in every three people are obese, per a New York City Department of Health phone survey.

Compare that to Battery Park City and Tribeca, where it’s estimated that fewer than one in every 10 residents are commuting more than an hour each way, and less than one in 10 residents are obese.

Claudia Matanza commutes from Brighton Beach to Downtown Brooklyn to work at Chipotle, which takes between 40 minutes to an hour depending on the state of the Q train. She says her commute sucks up her free time.

“Going back and forth on the train takes a lot of time,” she says. “And I already work a lot. When I get home, I just wanna relax.”

The data shows that Matanza is not alone: As the proportion increases of workers commuting more than an hour one way, so does the rate of people who report not having exercised in the past 30 days.

“Sometimes I can drive my mom’s car, but that’s only a little faster,” Matanza says. “I wish I could work closer so I have more time for myself, definitely.”

See it: Explore the relationship between commute times and obesity rates in your neighborhood.

Christine Hoehner, a former public health researcher at Washington University in St. Louis, confirmed that inability to exercise was likely one of the reasons longer commute times led to health issues.

Hoehner authored a 2012 study that found greater commuting distances are associated with exercising less and weighing more. She says the study provides insights into the links between longer commutes and “cardiovascular mortality.”

“Our commute is part of our daily lives, and people seeing that it could affect their health really struck a chord with the public,” says Hoehner.

There is a chance that both commute times and obesity are related to income, however, when comparing two communities with similar mean household incomes, as done below, an increase in the percentage of people commuting over 60 minutes one way is still associated with an increase in obesity rate.

Bushwick and Brighton Beach/Coney Island have relatively similar median household incomes, but there are large differences in the percentage of commuters with long commutes and obesity rate. Graphic by Laura Laderman/Measure of America.

James Raskin makes an hourlong commute from Bushwick to Resorts World Casino in Queens where he works as a security guard. He says the time spent on the train is a nuisance, especially now that the L train has become less reliable.

“I’m to the point where I don’t even use the L,” says Raskin. “Which means my commute is that much longer.

“I stopped cooking as much, for sure, while the L has been so slow, “says Raskin. “Sitting on the train for two hours a day sucks, but it’s part of the job.”

Raskin’s commute has been elongated by delays. But for Brooklynites farther from their workplace, an hourlong commute is a daily reality.

There are ways to reduce the negative health outcomes associated with longer commutes, according to researchers. In the health impact assessment report published about the L-train shutdown, the authors recommended that the city implement local or mobile food markets, place healthy meal options near transit hubs and collaborate with food subscription services. However, there is yet to be a city-led effort to address health disparities in areas with historically longer commutes.

As New York’s population continues to grow — and commutes become longer for those who can’t afford to live close to their workplaces — the physical health of entire neighborhoods could be at stake.

This report is a Brooklyn Eagle collaboration with Measure of America, an initiative of the Social Science Research Council to bring a data-driven approach to well-being and opportunity in the U.S.

Leave a Comment

Leave a Comment

1 Comment

  1. Cressie2949

    Unfortunately as gentrification continues to spread across the urban city forcing lower income individuals to seek housing outside of the city limits will only add to this “concern”. Attach the rising cost of healthy “organic” foods; I.e. A burger fries and a shake cost less that a normal size well-constructed salad. I believe ALL of these play a considerable factor in your findings and albeit a Pandora’s Box of issues with no easy solutions it is worthy of notation.