New York City

Conviction of ex-speaker Silver sends NY politics into turmoil

December 1, 2015 By David Klepper and Larry Neumeister Associated Press
Former New York Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver speaks as he exits Manhattan federal court following his conviction on corruption charges on Monday, Nov. 30. AP Photo/Bryan R. Smith
Share this:

The conviction of former Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver has shaken New York politics down to the granite foundations of the state Capitol, provoking fresh calls to overhaul a system that has stubbornly clung to its long history of corruption.

A jury convicted the 71-year-old Manhattan Democrat on Monday on charges that he traded favors for $4 million in kickbacks from a cancer researcher and real estate developers.

The rapid downfall was as shocking to lawmakers as it was troubling to longtime observers of New York politics.

“A political earthquake has hit Albany,” said Blair Horner, legislative director for the New York Public Interest Research Group. “This is a stinging rebuke to the ‘Albany business as usual’ defense and a clarion call to clean up state ethics.”

Silver, first elected in 1976, plans to appeal. He was ousted as speaker following his January arrest and lost his legislative seat upon conviction. He remains free on bail but faces decades in prison when he is sentenced.

For two decades, Silver loomed large as one of Albany’s “three men in a room,” who along with the Senate leader and the governor negotiated budgets, cut deals and defined New York’s brash brand of backroom politics.

Gov. Andrew Cuomo and Silver’s successor as speaker, Bronx Democrat Carl Heastie, said the conviction shows the need for stronger ethics rules.

“Words simply aren’t enough,” Heastie said following the verdict. “We will continue to work to root out corruption and demand more of elected officials when it comes to ethical conduct.”

Cuomo said the verdict showed “it is time for the Legislature to take seriously the need for reform. There will be zero tolerance for the violation of the public trust in New York.”

The list of possible reforms already was long before Silver was arrested: Term limits, restrictions on lawmakers’ outside income, new campaign finance rules and tougher ethics enforcement all have been suggested, only to languish on the legislative agenda.

Thirty lawmakers have left office since 2000 because of criminal charges or allegations of ethical misconduct. The Senate’s former No. 2 member, Republican Thomas Libous, was sentenced to house arrest last week for lying to the FBI. Ex-Senate Leader Dean Skelos, R-Long Island, is on trial for charges that he extorted bribes and jobs for his son.

In just the past five years, one Albany lawmaker was convicted of taking bribes from a carnival promoter. A second entered into a sham marriage in order to become a citizen. A third was accused of harassing female staffers and forcing one to touch cancerous tumors on his neck and armpit.

“The bell could not be ringing louder for real reform in Albany than it is right now,” said Assemblyman Todd Kaminsky, a former corruption prosecutor now in his first term.

After Silver’s arrest, the Legislature passed modest changes, including a requirement that lawmakers disclose more about their private income. Calls for greater changes, and a special session devoted to ethics, went nowhere.

Members of the Assembly’s Republican minority said they were skeptical of Democrats now calling for changes. Assemblyman David DiPietro, R-East Aurora, noted that many initially stood by Silver following his arrest.

“Until more elected criminals are held accountable, the New York State Assembly cannot be taken seriously,” he said.

The prosecution was a marquee case in Manhattan U.S. Attorney Preet Bharara’s quest to clean up what he has called Albany’s “cauldron of corruption.”

“Sheldon Silver got justice, and at long last, so did the people of New York,” Bharara said.

Prosecutors said Silver traded his office for $4 million in kickbacks from a cancer researcher and real estate developers and earned an additional $1 million through investments.

Silver did not testify during his trial and called no witnesses. Dr. Robert Taub told jurors he steered numerous patients with asbestos-related cancer to Silver’s law firm, enabling the legislator to pocket $3 million in referral fees. Meanwhile, testimony and evidence revealed, Silver caused $500,000 in taxpayer funds to go to Taub’s research projects and helped his son and daughter get a job and an internship.

Prosecutors said Silver delivered tax-abatement and rent-control legislation that favored developers while big developers hired a small law firm that secretly sent him $700,000 in fees.

Juror Arleen Phillips, who asked the judge to be excused from the case during deliberations because she said her fellow jurors were making her uncomfortable, eventually voted to convict. She told reporters that she initially doubted Silver was guilty, while most others wanted to convict, but changed her mind because Silver kept the dealings secret.

“Why was this kind of hidden?” she said, according to WNYC. “So I had my doubts at that point.”

Outside federal court on Monday, Silver said he thinks after the legal challenges, he’ll “get results. I’m disappointed right now.”


Leave a Comment

Leave a Comment