Dining Out: A Mexican food home away from home at Casa Vieja
When you dine at Casa Vieja, you are more than just a customer—you are like a guest in Enedina and Magdaleno Peña’s home.
The Sunset Park couple opened their family-run restaurant five years ago after two decades of working in other kitchens and running a mobile food and drink cart in the Red Hook ballfields. Now, they are successfully introducing even more people to their world of homemade authentic Mexican food, made fresh to order every day.
The most popular dishes on the menu include the enchiladas, tampiqueñas and burritos, and it is easy to see why. Enchiladas De Mole Poblano ($10) delivers three soft corn tortillas stuffed with your choice of Cotija cheese, vegetables, meat or shrimp, smothered with a thick, savory-sweet, dark sauce tinged with the heat of poblano peppers and the sweetness of chocolate. On its own, each bite is a pleasant surprise for your senses; when smushed with a forkful of fresh rice, beans and avocado, though, the combination of cool and complex just goes to another level.